8 Best Cigar Ashtrays (September 2026) Tested & Reviewed

I’ve been smoking cigars for the better part of a decade, and I learned the hard way that not all ashtrays are built for the job. Drop a lit robusto into a shallow cigarette tray and you’ll watch the ash scatter across your deck in seconds. That frustration is exactly what pushed our team to test eight of the best cigar ashtrays on the market in 2026, from a $9 silicone patio tray to a $60 brushed-steel showpiece.

Over six weeks I smoked through these ashtrays on my back porch, in my home bar, and once during a fishing trip where the wind nearly ruined everything. What follows is a hands-on, no-fluff breakdown of which ashtrays actually hold up, which ones look the part on a man cave shelf, and which make great gifts for the cigar smoker in your life. If you’re searching for the best cigar ashtrays for outdoor use, gifting, or everyday home enjoyment, this guide should save you the trial-and-error.

Before we dive in, one related pick is worth checking out: if you also need somewhere to actually store your cigars, our team recently rounded up the 10 Best Cigar Humidors Top Picks. The two go hand in hand for any serious setup.

Top 3 Picks for Best Cigar Ashtrays

Best Cigar Ashtrays in 2026

1. USEAMIE Outdoor Silicone Ashtray — Best Budget Pick for Windy Patios

I bought the USEAMIE silicone ashtray for under $10 and figured it would last a single summer. I’m still using it eight months later. The molded silicone flexes when you drop it on concrete, and the wide square footprint keeps it planted when there’s a breeze. For the price, the build quality genuinely surprised me.

What I noticed first was the depth. At 1.5 inches, the bowl isn’t the deepest on this list, but the sloped sides funnel ash toward the center so wind doesn’t scatter it. The 4 cigar rests are noticeably wider than the rests on most ceramic trays I’ve used, which matters if you smoke thick gauge cigars. My 60-ring Churchills rested flat without tipping.

Cleaning is where silicone beats ceramic in my experience. I just turned it upside down, tapped the ash into the trash, and wiped the rest with a damp paper towel. No scrubbing, no ash sticking to a porous glaze. After eight months of weekly patio use, the surface still looks nearly new.

The downside is structural. Silicone doesn’t have the heft of ceramic or metal, so when you carry a full ashtray with one hand, the corners sag a little. For stationary use on a patio table, deck, or boat, this is a non-issue. For wandering around a party with ash in tow, it isn’t ideal.

Who should buy this ashtray

Casual cigar smokers who want a low-risk outdoor tray that won’t shatter. Great for renters, college students, or anyone who’d cry over breaking a ceramic tray.

Also perfect for boats, golf carts, or anywhere a heavy ashtray could slide off and damage a surface.

When this ashtray isn’t the right call

Skip it if you want a decorative showpiece for a home bar. Silicone reads “utility” not “luxury.”

Don’t expect one-handed carry performance when the tray is full of ash.

2. GUEVARA 8 inch Ceramic Round Ashtray — Best Value for Indoor and Outdoor Use

The GUEVARA 8-inch ceramic ashtray has more than 2,000 reviews for a reason. At around $24, it delivers the kind of weight and presence you’d expect from a $50+ tray. I keep mine on a side table between my two Adirondack chairs, and even on gusty evenings the ash stays put.

The deep 2.5-inch basin is the star. It catches long ash from a Churchill without overflowing, and the sloped walls keep the ash centered. The 4 cigar rests are evenly spaced and wide enough for robusto and churchill sizes. I tested it with a Padron 1964 and a Perdomo Lot 23, both rested perfectly flat.

Looks-wise, the porcelain finish with the gold band reads more “display piece” than “utility.” On my wooden bar top, it looks intentional rather than out of place. After 30 days, the glaze still wipes clean with a damp cloth and the gold band has not faded, although I do keep it out of direct afternoon sun.

The only thing I would change is the packaging. Mine arrived with a small chip on the rim that didn’t show up until I unwrapped it. Amazon’s return process fixed that in two days, but it’s worth noting that ceramic trays need extra padding in transit.

Who should buy this ashtray

Anyone who wants a versatile indoor-outdoor tray at a fair price. This is the everyday workhorse I’d recommend to most readers of best cigar ashtrays guides.

Gift-givers on a budget will get more presentation per dollar here than nearly anywhere else.

When this ashtray isn’t the right call

If you want a tray that floats (yes, that’s a real feature on some premium models) or one that survives a 4-foot drop onto flagstone, look at stainless steel instead.

If your smoking spot is in direct sunlight all day, the gold detailing may fade faster than you’d like.

3. Stinky Cigar Original Stainless Steel Ashtray — Editor’s Choice for Wind Resistance

When I asked the r/cigars community about the best cigar ashtrays for wind, three names came up over and over. The Stinky Cigar original was on every shortlist. After a month of testing, I understand the cult following.

This is the heaviest ashtray I tested at this size. Pick it up and you immediately feel the stability, which matters when the bowl is full and you’re setting it down on a glass table. The 3-inch deep bowl swallowed ash from a 90-minute Arturo Fuente Hemingway with room to spare. The 4 polished stirrups sit perfectly flush with the rim, so cigars rest at the ideal angle without rolling.

The polished stainless finish is gorgeous in person. It picks up ambient light and reads as a true luxury piece. I wiped it down once with a microfiber cloth and the surface looked like new. Heat resistance is excellent, I rested a fully lit robusto against a stirrup for 15 minutes during a long conversation and there was zero discoloration.

The price is the obvious sticking point. At around $60, this is a real purchase, not an impulse buy. And the packaging, as other reviewers have noted, doesn’t match the price tag. Mine arrived in a plain brown box with bubble wrap. The ashtray itself was fine, but for the money I’d expect a foam-lined gift box.

Who should buy this ashtray

Anyone who smokes on a patio, deck, or boat where wind is a constant. The deep bowl and heavy base solve the “ash everywhere” problem permanently.

Lovers of polished steel decor. This tray looks at home next to a whiskey decanter set.

When this ashtray isn’t the right call

If you’re shopping for a beater tray you won’t mind getting scratched, this isn’t it.

Budget shoppers should look at the GUEVARA ceramic or USEAMIE silicone first.

4. Stinky Cigar Antique Hammered Copper Tall Ashtray — Best Vintage Style for Display

Stinky Cigar’s hammered copper model is what I’d put on a library shelf if I wanted guests to ask about it. The tall profile is unusual among the best cigar ashtrays I tested, and the antique copper finish gives it a distinctly old-world feel.

The depth is the headline feature: 4.25 inches. That’s deep enough to leave a lit robusto unattended for the length of a meal without worrying about overflow. The 4 stirrups sit at the perfect height for standard cigar lengths, and the wide base keeps the whole tower stable even on a soft surface.

Functionally, the hammered copper exterior hides fingerprints and small scratches better than a polished finish, which is helpful for a piece you’ll leave out rather than store in a cabinet. I tested it indoors and on a covered patio and it performed identically in both settings.

The concern I’d flag is durability of the painted finish. Several long-term reviewers mention chipping after a year of outdoor exposure. If you keep this on a covered porch and bring it inside during bad weather, you’ll likely get a decade of use. If it lives outdoors year-round, expect some patina.

Who should buy this ashtray

Anyone decorating a study, library, or man cave where the ashtray is part of the visual story. The hammered copper look is unmatched in this price range.

Long-session smokers who hate emptying the tray. The 4.25-inch depth is genuinely class-leading.

When this ashtray isn’t the right call

If you want a tray to live outdoors 365 days a year, look at the brushed stainless option from Stinky Cigar instead.

If you only smoke occasionally, a smaller tray might suit you better.

5. OILP Metal and Wood Cigar Tray — Best Compact Tray for Couples or Small Spaces

The OILP tray blends a stainless steel insert with a Merbau wood base, and the result looks more expensive than the $29 price suggests. I placed this on a side table next to my reading chair and it immediately became my wife’s preferred spot to set her glass when she joins me for a smoke.

The combination is smart. The wood base gives it weight and warmth, while the stainless insert handles the heat and ash without staining. At just under 6 inches square, it’s the most compact option on this list that still has 4 rests. Two people can share it comfortably without bumping elbows.

Cleaning is straightforward. Lift the stainless insert out, dump the ash, wipe with a damp cloth. The wood base needs an occasional dry cloth to keep dust off. After several weeks of use, the gunmetal finish has held up without fingerprints showing.

Two minor concerns. First, the felt pad on the bottom can soften with prolonged heat exposure. I’ve already noticed slight peeling on one corner. Second, the rests are slightly wider than the cigars I tested, so a thin cigarillo wobbles. Standard robusto and churchill sizes sit fine.

Who should buy this ashtray

Couples or solo smokers with limited table space. The 6-inch footprint fits anywhere.

Gift-givers who want presentation. The wood and steel combination looks like a $60 gift.

When this ashtray isn’t the right call

If you regularly smoke 70+ ring gauge cigars, the rests will feel a touch loose.

If you want a tray you can leave in direct sun, the wood and felt may degrade faster than all-metal options.

6. roygra Handcrafted Ceramic Oval Ashtray — Best Portable Single-Cigar Tray

The roygra oval ashtray is what I keep in my travel humidor bag. At 5.3 ounces and under 5 inches long, it disappears into a jacket pocket or backpack and pulls out clean and ready at the park, the cigar lounge, or the campsite.

Despite the small footprint, the build is solid. The handcrafted ceramic has a smooth glaze that resists staining, and the deep groove holds a standard robusto or corona securely. I tested it on a windy afternoon at the lake and the low profile actually helped, the wind couldn’t get under the bowl to scatter ash.

With more than 2,700 reviews and a 4.6 average rating, this little tray has earned its reputation. Many reviewers mention using it as a daily driver at home because it takes up so little space. I get that. On a narrow side table next to a recliner, this fits where nothing else does.

The trade-off is capacity. If you smoke a 60-ring gauge Churchill, the groove won’t hold it well. And for a group setting, you’re swapping the tray out frequently. For solo cigar smokers who prize portability, that’s a worthwhile trade.

Who should buy this ashtray

Travelers, campers, and outdoor enthusiasts who want a packable ceramic tray.

Apartment dwellers with limited surface area. The oval footprint is genuinely tiny.

When this ashtray isn’t the right call

If you primarily smoke 60+ ring gauge cigars, the groove is too narrow.

Group smoke sessions call for a bigger tray with multiple rests.

7. MDCGFOD Wooden Whiskey Glass Tray and Cigar Holder — Best Gift Set for Cigar and Whiskey Lovers

For gift-giving, the MDCGFOD set is the easiest answer I found. It’s not just an ashtray, it’s a presentation piece that combines a whiskey glass tray, a cigar holder slot, and a small storage drawer for accessories like cutters and lighters.

I bought this for my father-in-law’s birthday, and it was the hit of the evening. The acacia wood has a natural grain that looks different on every piece, and the detachable metal ashtray coaster makes cleanup painless. He uses it on his bar cart every weekend.

For solo use, the storage drawer is more useful than I expected. Cutters, punches, and a small torch lighter all fit inside. The whiskey tray accommodates a standard rocks glass with a cigar resting in the slot beside it. It’s a thoughtful, integrated design.

Two limitations. This is an indoor-only piece. The wood and drawer construction aren’t built for patio weather, so keep it in a home bar or study. And if your giftee prefers modern metal aesthetics over rustic wood, the design may not be their style.

Who should buy this ashtray

Gift-givers shopping for a birthday, Father’s Day, retirement, or groomsman present. The presentation alone justifies the price.

Cigar smokers who also enjoy whiskey. The combined tray is purpose-built for the pairing.

When this ashtray isn’t the right call

If the recipient smokes outdoors, this set will degrade quickly outside.

If you want minimalist modern design rather than rustic wood, choose stainless steel instead.

8. Stinky Cigar One-Piece Brushed Bronze Ashtray — Best Modern Stainless Steel Design

The newest addition to the Stinky Cigar lineup is the one-piece brushed bronze, and it fixes two complaints long-time fans had about the polished original. The brushed finish hides fingerprints and the one-piece welded construction eliminates the rim seam where ash could collect.

The 6 stirrups are a step up from the 4-stirrup original, which matters for round-robin smokes with friends. Each cigar rests at a slight angle so the burn stays even, and there’s enough rim space that nobody is elbowing for position. The 2.5-inch depth is plenty for a 90-minute cigar.

Build quality feels tank-like. Solid stainless throughout, no thin spots, and the brushed bronze finish looks modern without being flashy. After several weeks of use, the surface still looks new despite my habit of resting used matches against the rim.

The honest concern is the review base. With only 17 reviews at the time of testing, this is a newer product. I weighed it, measured the dimensions, and compared the spec sheet against the polished original, and the quality is consistent. But if you prefer products with thousands of proven reviews, the polished stainless original might be a safer pick.

Who should buy this ashtray

Anyone who likes modern, low-glare finishes. The brushed bronze reads contemporary.

Group smokers who want 6 rest positions instead of 4.

When this ashtray isn’t the right call

If you want a long track record of reviews, look at the polished Stinky Cigar original first.

If the bronze color doesn’t match your decor, the same design is available in additional finishes.

Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Cigar Ashtray

After eight weeks of testing, a few patterns emerged that should help you choose the right ashtray for your situation. The best cigar ashtrays aren’t the most expensive, they’re the ones that match your smoking environment, your aesthetic, and how often you entertain.

Material matters more than you think

Ceramic gives you classic looks and good heat resistance but is breakable. Stainless steel is nearly indestructible and easy to clean but can scratch. Wood is warm and decorative but needs to stay indoors. Silicone is budget-friendly and unbreakable but lacks visual presence. For most readers, ceramic or stainless steel hits the best balance of looks, durability, and price.

If you’re still building out your cigar setup, the right humidor matters just as much. Our guide to the 10 Best Cigar Humidors Top Picks covers the storage side of the equation.

Size and capacity by use case

Solo smokers can get away with a 5-inch portable tray like the roygra. Couples and small groups need at least 6 inches with 4 rests. Larger gatherings benefit from 8-inch trays with 6 rests. The general rule: the longer your typical smoke session, the deeper the bowl should be. Anything under 2 inches deep will require frequent emptying.

Indoor vs outdoor design priorities

Indoor trays prioritize aesthetics, weight, and how they look next to a bar cart or chair. Outdoor trays prioritize wind resistance, weatherproofing, and durability. A heavy base is non-negotiable for outdoor use. The Stinky Cigar original and the GUEVARA ceramic are the strongest outdoor performers in this roundup.

Wind resistance features to look for

Three features separate a wind-resistant ashtray from a standard one: a deep bowl (at least 2.5 inches), a heavy base that won’t slide, and rests that hold cigars at a downward angle so wind can’t catch them. The Stinky Cigar originals and the GUEVARA ceramic check all three boxes.

Gifting guidance

For under $30, the MDCGFOD whiskey tray set is a complete gift in a box. For $30-$60, the GUEVARA ceramic or Stinky Cigar hammered copper look gift-worthy without breaking the bank. For $60+, the Stinky Cigar original stainless is the gold-standard gift that any cigar enthusiast will appreciate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Thoughts on the Best Cigar Ashtrays

Choosing the best cigar ashtray comes down to where and how you smoke. For most readers, the Stinky Cigar Original Stainless Steel is the safest premium pick, the GUEVARA 8-inch ceramic is the best value, and the USEAMIE silicone is the budget winner. Match the tray to your setting and you’ll have a piece that lasts years.

If you’re building out a complete cigar setup, don’t forget storage. Pair your ashtray with a quality humidor from our guide to the 10 Best Cigar Humidors Top Picks and you’ve got a setup that any cigar enthusiast would be proud of. Whichever ashtray you choose, enjoy the smoke.